In a recent decision, the Social Chamber of the High Court of Justice of Castilla y León has ruled that companies may retract a disciplinary dismissal before the date set for its effectiveness, provided that certain requirements are met.
The specific case that gave rise to the ruling referred to the disciplinary dismissal of an employee by a company. The letter of dismissal set the effective date of the dismissal for one month after its communication. However, before that date, the company decided to retract its decision and informed the employee of its intention to maintain the employment relationship.
The employee, in disagreement with this decision, challenged the dismissal before the labor courts. However, both the Social Court and the Social Chamber of the Superior Court of Justice of Castilla y León rejected his claim, considering that the company’s retraction was valid.
The Chamber, in its argumentation, pointed out that although Article 55.1 of the Workers’ Statute establishes that disciplinary dismissal is not subject to a notice period, this does not mean that the effective date of the dismissal must necessarily coincide with the date of communication. In this sense, the Chamber considered that the company may set an effective date after the date of the notice of dismissal, provided that such date is not prior to the date of dismissal and does not respond to unjustified or disproportionate notice periods.
Likewise, the Court emphasized that the employer’s retraction must be made in a reliable manner, communicating to the employee in a clear and express manner the decision to annul the dismissal and the maintenance of the employment relationship.
This ruling represents an important advance in terms of workers’ rights, since it opens up the possibility for companies to reconsider their disciplinary dismissal decision before it becomes effective.
Analysis:
The ruling of the High Court of Justice of Castilla y León is good news for workers, as it allows them to have a second chance in case the company has decided to dismiss them disciplinarily.
However, it is important to highlight that the company’s retraction is not an automatic right of the worker, but depends on the company’s will and the fulfillment of the requirements established in the case law.
On the other hand, the ruling also has implications for companies, as it forces them to be more cautious when making the decision to dismiss an employee for disciplinary reasons.
In short, the ruling of the High Court of Justice of Castilla y León contributes to a better balance in labor relations, by protecting the rights of workers while recognizing the power of companies to modify their decisions in certain cases.
The recent ruling of the High Court of Justice of Castilla y León opens a new avenue for the resolution of disputes arising from disciplinary dismissals. The possibility of corporate retraction, although subject to certain requirements, represents an advance in the protection of workers’ rights.
For more information, please contact Labor consulting
If you found it interesting share it on social networks, thanks!
